Converting Quarterly title
The Official
Technical Magazine
of AIMCAL
small AIMCAL logo
  Search

Vacuum Web Coating

Blogmaster: Dr. Charles A. Bishop

06

We came across one question answered by you ( dtd.Feb.2, 2009. "How are these pin holes formed ?")  on internet regarding the pin holes in metallized PET film.

Is that pin holes are like sieve or unmetallized / metal removed portion of the film?

How to detect the same is only metal removed area or see through hole.

Pl. advice.

Answer

Pin holes or Pin windows is a catch-all term that is used to describe small areas that at first sight appear to have no metal coating present.  On occasions it is possible to do some analysis on these areas and come up with some information about how they were formed.

If there was a particle of debris that was metallized and then removed after metallisation there is usually an area of uncoated polymer were the particle was positioned which has a small area of thinner metallisation surrounding this uncoated area.  This thinner metal is due to the debris blocking the metal flux for part of the time in the deposition zone.  As the debris first enters the deposition zone the area behind the debris is shadowed from the metal flux but as the debris traverses the zone this shadowing becomes less until the centre point where there is minimum shadowing. After the mid point the shadowing then is on the opposite side of the debris and this gets larger until the debris exits the deposition zone.

If the debris was not rolled away but slid along there would be an uncoated area that then had a scratch away from the pinhole.  The scratch may have the metal completely removed or may just have the metal thinned.

By comparison a pinhole formed by pickoff is likely to have a pinhole with no graded metal thickness but generally has a step change in the metal thickness with either the full metal thickness or zero metal thickness where the metal has been removed.

If the pinhole is due to spitting there is likely to be a small particle left at the centre of the pinhole and also some heat damage to the polymer where the particle has impacted.

When the metallized film is held up to a strong light there may be many more pinholes visible than if the film is held up to a weaker light.  The reason for this is that a number of the pinholes may be not really holes in the metal coating but simply areas of thinner metallisation that produce a significant difference in contrast.  Areas where there is residual oligomer on the surface can result in these thinner coated areas.  The oligomer can have a significantly lower melting temperature than the polymer. The oligomer can be heated by the evaporation source and the oligomer may be evaporated by the heat and as the oligomer evaporates it prevents the aluminium form depositing. If there is a lot of oligomer this may prevent all the aluminium from depositing or if there is a lower amount of oligomer then once the oligomer has evaporated there may be some metal deposited but thinner than the rest of the metal deposited on the clean surface.

With respect to the final performance of the coated polymer then all holes with no metal deposited will have no barrier performance whatsoever. It does not matter how the holes were formed the result is the same, no metal results in no barrier.   Where the metal is thinner the barrier performance will be better than where there is no metal but less than where there is full metal.

The number of holes is dependant upon the amount of debris on the substrate before starting to metallize the web, the amount of oligomer or other low molecular weight material is present on the web surface, as well as being dependant upon the quality of adhesion and web surface roughness along with other factors such as roll tension and handling quality.

I hope this gives you a more complete knowledge of pinholes.  

[Read More...]

Comments

Tuesday, August 23, 2011 7:53 AM
This could not possbliy have been more helpful!
#436 Shwaytaj
Saturday, April 28, 2012 10:01 AM
Could you please explain this point : By comparison a pinhole formed by pickoff is likely to have a pinhole with no graded metal thickness but generally has a step change in the metal thickness with either the full metal thickness or zero metal thickness where the metal has been removed.

I was not able to get it clearly
#437 Charles Bishop
Saturday, April 28, 2012 5:35 PM
If the pinhole is formed by a particle being moved the particle may shadow the deposition leading to a graded coating at the edge or if the particle is moved during deposition there will be a partial coating.

A pinhole produced by pick off means that the coating will be removed after the deposition has been completed and it is able to be removed because of poor adhesion and so may not be related to any particle and so the coating thickness is more likely to be the full thickness and so where it is removed the edge is more likely to be a sharp step change between coated and non-coated film.

I hope this clarifies the difference.
CAB

Post Comment

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above:

Blogmaster

Charles Bishop photo

Dr. Charles A. Bishop

Charles is a toolmaker by trade after completing a mechanical engineering apprenticeship. He then entered University and obtained a Bachelors degree in materials engineering with a Diploma in Industrial Studies. During his final year he first started work on vacuum based research, helping develop a process for manufacturing titanium based bone implants for tendon location. He went on to obtain a Masters degree and Doctorate following further research into vacuum deposition processes. During this time and as a postgraduate he also worked as a consultant.

Charles next spent time in industry working for various divisions of ICI including polyesters, nylon, Imagedata, Flex Products Inc., and explosives as well as contributing to other projects. In 1998 he took the opportunity to return to consultancy work and set up his own company.

Charles has more than 30 years experience in vacuum deposition mainly onto flexible webs. He has regularly contributed papers to conferences and recently has edited this blog on behalf of AIMCAL as well as being one of their presenters for various webinars and the more formal Converting School courses.

Charles has also published 2 books, Vacuum deposition onto webs, films and foils and Roll-to-roll vacuum deposition of barrier coatings.